Up until about 24 hours before the 2022 NBA draft, it was widely believed that Paolo Banchero would be the third player off the board, with Jabari Smith considered likely to be the Magic‘s pick at No. 1 and Chet Holmgren the favorite to follow him at No. 2. Banchero was expected to be selected third overall by the Rockets.
Instead, it was Banchero who was the first player drafted, while Holmgren still went to the Thunder and Smith headed to Houston rather than Orlando.
Through the first month of the 2022/23 regular season, it’s looking like the Magic made the right call.
Banchero has been one of the NBA’s most productive rookies in years in the early going, averaging an impressive 23.5 points, 8.3 rebounds, and 3.6 assists in 34.7 minutes per game. Smith, meanwhile, has struggled mightily, making just 31.3% of his shots from the field en route to modest averages of 10.3 PPG and 6.8 RPG in 29.7 MPG. And while it may be unfair to dock Holmgren for having suffered a season-ending foot injury before training camps begin, his slight frame was considered a possible red flag for teams picking at the top of the draft.
Banchero is the odds-on favorite for the Rookie of the Year award at this point, but it looks like he’ll face some stiff competition from a couple players selected just outside of the top three.
Pacers guard Bennedict Mathurin has arguably been just as impressive as Banchero in his first 12 NBA games, averaging 19.9 PPG, 3.9 RPG, and 2.3 APG with a sparkling .456/.453/.831 shooting line in just 28.1 MPG. If Indiana continues to bring him off the bench and he keeps playing at his current level, he could be a legitimate threat to win two end-of-season awards — Rookie of the Year and Sixth Man of the Year.
Pistons guard Jaden Ivey, meanwhile, hasn’t been scoring at quite the same rate as Banchero or Mathurin, but he ranks third among rookies in points per game (15.8 PPG), fourth in rebounding (5.1 RPG), and first in assists (3.8 APG). It’s not just a case of him benefiting from a high usage rate either, as his shooting percentages (.446/.352/.727) are very solid for a 20-year-old adjusting to the NBA.
No. 4 overall pick Keegan Murray is off to a slightly slower start after returning from a bout with COVID-19, but the Kings forward has averaged 11.9 PPG on .446/.361/.778 shooting and could continue to boost those numbers as the season progresses.
It’s still very early in the season, and as we saw a year ago with Cade Cunningham and Jalen Green, it sometimes takes highly touted rookies a little time to adjust to the NBA and begin scoring efficiently, so we could see youngsters like Smith and Murray come on strong in the second half.
For now though, we want to know your initial thoughts on this year’s rookie class.
Did you expect Banchero and Mathurin to be this good this fast, or have they surprised you? Do you think they’ll come back to earth while other rookies get hot, or will the Rookie of the Year race ultimately come down to the Magic forward and the Pacers guard? Are you worried about Smith, or do you expect him to be fine after he endures some growing pains? Are there other rookies in this class – including perhaps Shaedon Sharpe, Jeremy Sochan, or Tari Eason – who have impressed you so far?
Head to the comment section below to share your thoughts!
Shaedon Sharpe is a beast. I think he will be getting honorable mentions by the end of the season. I also like Jalen Williams in OKC. He could also be one of the late surging Rookie’s. Duren/Kessler have been good too.
Houston, Sacramento, and Detroit are perfect examples of why tanking for high draft picks is a terrible strategy.
What’s Detroit done wrong?
They had Reggie Jackson, Blake Griffin and Andre Drummond and were constantly struggling to make the playoffs.
They cleared all three guys and didn’t get much back in return. So far (2 seasons) have drafted really well with the exception being Killian Hayes and now look like a promising young side.
Cade Cunningham is a wry good young point guard, Jaden Ivey has shown that he will be a really good fit beside him at the 2. Then they have the likes of Bey, Bagley, Stewart, Livers, Duren and so on.
Right now they have the third best record, imagine if they add Victor Wembanyama to that team. To go with that, Draymond is a real possibility to leave GSW either at the deadline or in the offseason. Imagine if they could him to return home.
Cade Ivey Bey Green Victor
That in all seriousness is a playoff side that’ll only improve over time
Didnt think Portland would be willing to use Sharpe early on, after hos injury in summer league, and having not played in so long, even though I thought they needed him on the wing behind Josh Hart, but he has been healthy, and very useful for them, and exactly what they needed, and is 1 of the big reasons they are where they are so far, in my opinion
I think Jabari Smith is facing an unfortunate situation with the rotation decision in Houston that puts him in a tough spot to succeed. He isn’t a guy that will go get his own shot. I’m not arguing that, but I think the other 4 guys starting next to him all need the ball in their hands
Shame we can’t enjoy Holmgren…
Banchero as awesome as advertised…
Jabari Smith as unimpressive as everyone expected…
I expected more from Keegan….
Mathurin the positive surprise so far!
Ivey as flat as DET, so no surprise there!
Lol @ “widely believed”. Sad part is that yall refuse to learn from your mistakes… Glad to see Mathurin’s bandwagon filling up but you just know his cornrows are gonna make him a target for the haters sooner or later… Please don’t be like Joel & discount this former teammate of Paolo either, he’s gonna challenge for 1 of those All-Rookie spots as well… link to m.youtube.com
Relax Hawk fanatic …… it was widely thought that way. If Knicks listen to me. We would have had a shot at Mathurin …….
Well yall were widely wrong lol. That’s what you get for being sheep & going off what some random sportswriters say instead of watching these guys yourself & coming up with your own judgment. It should have been obv that Paolo was going 1st even before the ncaa tournament
Yawn ……
This is a solid Rookie class. Is see the whole 1st as solid talent. A guy like MarJon who went to Bucks at 24. Looks like a solid piece. Top 10 all have a chance to be special. Banchero reminds me of old school 4s. Think Elvin Hayes ……. look him up. Great choice by Magic. Magic are loaded with 4s.
Milwaukee managed to get a better player at #24 in MarJon Beauchamp than what Washington got with Johnny Davis 9G-League) at #10.
Kenny Lofton to make a late run for Rookie of the year but ultimately it’s Paolos to lose with Benedict a clear second for now.
All rookie first team
Paolo Benedict Ivey Murray Lofton
Don’t count out Ivey or Murray just yet. Very early.
Really rate Ivey but Cade will be the more ball dominate player and the teams lack of suns will hold him back from making a real Cade. Murray off to a slow start really like him but he’s at the very best the third option on that team.
Paolos magic will probably have roughly as many wins as the kings (more than the pistons) with him being the number 1 option so I think that’ll always be the argument in his favour
How can you compare on the same performance level Mathurin to Banchero …. that’s a total lack of objectivity, to say the least !!
in 10 years Paolo is gonna be that ONE