Community Shootaround: Western All-Star Reserves

Last Thursday, the NBA revealed the 10 players – five from each conference – voted as starters for the 2025 All-Star Game. This coming Thursday, the All-Star reserves will be announced on TNT.

We opened up a discussion on Monday about which players were most deserving of All-Star reserve recognition in the Eastern Conference. Today, we’re shifting our focus to the Western Conference, where Nikola Jokic, Kevin Durant, LeBron James, Stephen Curry, and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander have been named starters.

That leaves seven spots to fill in the West — two in the backcourt and three in the frontcourt, along with a pair of wild cards. The reserves will be voted on by NBA coaches, not fans, but we want to get your feedback today on which players have earned those spots.

Naming his seven picks, Zach Harper of The Athletic prioritized frontcourt players, with Spurs big man Victor Wembanyama, Lakers forward/center Anthony Davis, and Thunder forward Jalen Williams joined by wild cards Alperen Sengun of the Rockets and Domantas Sabonis of the Kings. Harper’s two guards were Anthony Edwards of the Timberwolves and Norman Powell of the Clippers.

It looks like a pretty safe bet that Wembanyama and Davis will make the cut. They also showed up on John Hollinger’s seven-player list for The Athletic, as did Williams, Sabonis and Edwards, all of whom have very compelling cases too. However, Hollinger passed on Sengun and Powell in favor of Grizzlies big man Jaren Jackson Jr. and Mavericks guard Kyrie Irving.

Jackson would be an easy choice for me, and I was a little surprised not to see him among Harper’s picks. The former Defensive Player of the Year is once again anchoring Memphis on that end of the court while having the best offensive season of his career, with 22.8 points per game on .499/.355/.782 shooting. The Grizzlies rank third in the West with a 31-16 record despite Ja Morant missing 19 games so far. Jackson has arguably been the driving force behind that success.

If I had a vote, I’d make Wembanyama, Davis, and Jackson my frontcourt selections, with Edwards in the backcourt. The second backcourt spot is trickier.

Luka Doncic would be the obvious favorite if not for the injuries that have limited him to 22 games. Devin Booker and De’Aaron Fox have put up big scoring numbers, but their teams have hovered around .500 and their shooting percentages have been below their career rates. Irving has a solid case, as does James Harden, whom I’d put ahead of his Clippers teammate Powell due to his play-making and the fact that Powell greatly benefits from all the defensive attention on Harden.

As Hollinger notes, Williams doesn’t spend a whole lot of time at shooting guard but could perhaps qualify there for the sake of this exercise. Although his scoring stats aren’t as gaudy as some of his competitors, his two-way impact for the West’s top seed makes him a worthy candidate.

If I make Williams my second backcourt pick, I’d probably take Sabonis and Sengun as my wild cards, though as noted above, there are reasonable arguments to be made for Booker, Fox, Irving, Harden, Powell, and Doncic, among others.

We want to know what you think. Which seven players would you pick as All-Star reserves in the Western Conference? Is there anyone I didn’t mention who deserves serious consideration?

Head to the comment section below to weigh in with your thoughts!